3SOF

Public 3SOF Boards => Technical Analysis => Topic started by: snowgoose on August 13, 2005, 03:15:32 PM

Title: Logarithmic Charts vs. Other
Post by: snowgoose on August 13, 2005, 03:15:32 PM
When I tried to draw the same trendline on VPHM's chart that 3sof drew on the VPHM chart showing that it had tested support, I couldn't draw the trendline because my chart wasn't the same as the 3sof chart.  Then I unclicked "Logarithmic" and that fixed the problem and I was able to draw the same trendline that appeared here.  Should I not be using Logarithmic charts?  It sure does make a big difference in what you see sometimes!
Title: Re: Logarithmic Charts vs. Other
Post by: Ramsburg on August 13, 2005, 10:46:51 PM
Hi Snowgoose,

There is no specific rule about that...
I usually use normal charts, been doing that since 1997 in most of my TA's.

I only use semi-log scale, in some cases where it's completely impossible to do a normal TA on normal scale... But when I figure good and working patterns on a normal scale chart I just forget about the semi-log scale...

But there's a lot of controversial about this issue... For example, the semi-log chart gave a good exit signal on VPHM a few sessions ago... but the normal chart gave what seems to be a good entry point...

I'm sure there will be a lot of different opinions on this matter ;) It's a classic TA discussion... Applaud you for starting this subject !

best regards !
Title: Ramsburg/elite need input
Post by: stocky on August 14, 2005, 01:08:37 AM
Ramsburg/elite, can you arrange them in order of the best technical indicators in your opinon top to bottom.

Bullish Engulfing
Piercing Line
Morning Star
Bullish Harami   
Three White Soldiers
Title: Re: Logarithmic Charts vs. Other
Post by: eliteG on August 14, 2005, 01:26:23 AM
hey stocky

- my opinion is that they are all equally strong.  I never trade on just one reason.  So those japanese candlestick types are merely "1 reason" that hopefully I can combine with many other "reasons"..support, resistance, volume...

hey snowgoose

- i know what you're talking about.  Before 3sof I used mainly logarithmic charts!  Then I noticed most of the great chartists here using linear... and now I highly recommend it.  Like Ramsburg said  ;), for some pennies I have to use log to actually see the chart, lol, but otherwise its linear.  I guess switching back and forth might be useful sometimes...hmmm